Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History4.07 · Rating details · 59 Ratings · 6 Reviews
Heretical Essays is Patocka's final work, and one of his most exciting and iconoclastic. Patocka begins with prehistory, approached through the "natural world" as conceived by Husserl and Heidegger.
According to Patocka, nature is as an alien construct, and history, which began as a quest for higher meaning, ends with life as self-sustaining consumption. Patocka explains hoHeretical Essays is Patocka's final work, and one of his most exciting and iconoclastic. Patocka begins with prehistory, approached through the "natural world" as conceived by Husserl and Heidegger.
According to Patocka, nature is as an alien construct, and history, which began as a quest for higher meaning, ends with life as self-sustaining consumption. Patocka explains how Europe declined from its Greek heritage to seek power rather than truth, splintering into ethnic subdivisions, and then how the Enlightenment moved Europe from an ethical to a material orientation.
This book includes a translation of the Preface to the French Edition by Paul Ricoeur....more
Paperback, 200 pages
Published January 26th 1999 by Open Court (first published 1975)
Jan Patočka (1 June 1907 – 13 March 1977) was a Czech philosopher. Due to his contributions to phenomenology and the philosophy of history he is considered one of the most important philosophers of the 20th century. Having studied in Prague, Paris, Berlin and Freiburg, he was one of the last pupils of Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger. During his studies in Freiburg he was also tutored by Eugen Fink, a relationship which eventually turned into a lifelong philosophical friendship.
Patočka attended Jan Neruda Grammar School.
His works mainly dealt with the problem of the original, given world (Lebenswelt), its structure and the human position in it. He tried to develop this Husserlian concept under the influence of some core Heideggerian themes (e.g. historicity, technicity, etc.) On the other hand, he also criticised Heideggerian philosophy for not dealing sufficiently with the basic structures of being-in-the-world, which are not truth-revealing activities (this led him to an appreciation of the work of Hannah Arendt). From this standpoint he formulated his own original theory of "three movements of human existence": 1) receiving, 2) reproduction, 3) transcendence. He also translated many of Hegel's and Schelling's works into Czech. In his life time, he has published in Czech, German, and French.
Apart from his writing on the problem of the Lebenswelt, he wrote interpretations of Presocratic and classical Greek philosophy and several longer essays on the history of Greek ideas in the formation of our concept of Europe. Patočka's increasingly focused on the idea of Europe during the 1970s. As he was banned from teaching (see below), he held clandestine lectures in his private apartment on the Greek thought in general and on Plato in particular in the late 70s. These clandestine lectures are collectively known as Plato and Europe, and they are published under the same title in English. He also entered into discussions about modern Czech philosophy, art, history and politics. He was an esteemed scholar of Czech thinkers such as Komensky (b.1592) (also known as Comenius) and Masaryk (b.1850). In 1971, he has published a small treatise on Comenius in German titled Die Philosophy der Erziehung des J.A. Comenius (Comenius's Philosophy of Education). In 1977, his work on Masaryk culminated in ‘Two Studies on Masaryk, which was initially a privately circulated typescript.
Patočka's Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History is analyzed at length and with much care in Jacques Derrida's important book The Gift of Death. Derrida was the most recent person who wrote or conversed with Patočka's thought; Paul Ricoeur and Roman Jakobson (who respectively wrote the preface and afterword to the French edition of the Heretical Essays) are two further examples.
During the years 1939–1945, when the Czech universities were closed, as well as between 1951–1968 and from 1972 on, Patočka was banned from teaching. Only a few of his books were published and most of his work circulated only in the form of typescripts kept by students and disseminated mostly after his death. Along with other banned intellectuals he gave lectures at the so-called "Underground University", which was an informal institution that tried to offer a free, uncensored cultural education. In January 1977 he became one of the original signatories and main spokespersons for the Charter 77 (Charta 77) human rights movement in Czechoslovakia. For the three months after the Charter was released he was intensely active writing and speaking about the meaning of the Charter, in spite of his deteriorating health. He was also interrogated by the police regarding his involvement with the Charter movement, and on March 3, 1977 he was held by the police for ten hours, who had claimed that he would be allowed to speak in his role as a Charter spokesperson with a high-ranking official (in fact, this was a pretext to keep him from attending a reception at the West German embassy). He fell ill that evening and was taken to the hospital, where his health briefly improved, enabling him to give one final interview with Die Zeit and to write one final essay entitled "What We Can Expect from Charter 77." On March 11 he relapsed, and on March 13 he died of apoplexy, at the age of 69.
His brother František Patočka was a microbiologist.
List of works
- The Natural World As a Philosophical Problem [Přirozený svět jako filosofický problém]
- An Introduction to Husserl's Phenomenology [Úvod do Husserlovy fenomenologie]
- Aristotle, his Predecessors and his Heirs [Aristoteles, jeho předchůdci a dědicové]
- Body, Community, Language, World [Tělo, společenství, jazyk, svět]
- Negative Platonism [Negativní platónismus]
- Plato and Europe [Platón a Evropa]
- Who are the Czechs? [Co jsou Češi?]
- Care for the Soul [Péče o duši]
- Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History [Kacířské eseje o filosofii dějin]
- Two Studies on Masaryk [Dvě studie o Masarkyovi]
- “Wars of the Twentieth Century and the Twentieth Century as War”. Telos 30 (Winter 1976-77). New York: Telos Press.
- Jan Patocka: Philosophy and Selected Writings. Edited by Erazim Kohak. Chicago & London: The Chicago University Press, 1989.
- Body, Community, Language, World. Translated by Erazim Kohák. Edited by James Dodd. Chicago, IL: Open Court, 1998.
- Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History. Translated by Erazim Kohák. Edited by James Dodd. Chicago, IL: Open Court, 1996.
- An Introduction to Husserl's Phenomenology. Translated by Erazim Kohák. Edited by James Dodd. Chicago, IL: Open Court, 1996.
- Plato and Europe. Translated by Petr Lom. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2002.
- The Natural World as a Philosophical Problem. Translated by Erika Abrams. Edited by Ivan Chvatík and Ľubica Učnik. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 2016
- ^Erazim Kohak, “Jan Patočka: A Philosophical Biography” in (ed.) Erazim Kohak, Jan Patočka: Philosophy and Selected Writings (Chicago & London: The University of Chicago Press, 1989), p. 4.
- ^John Bolton, Worlds of Dissent (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2012), p. 159.
- Renaud Barbaras, Le mouvement de l'existence. Etudes sur la phénoménologie de Jan Patočka, Les Editions de la transparence, 2007
- Dalibor Truhlar, Jan Patočka. Ein Sokrates zwischen Husserl und Heidegger, Sonderpublikation des Universitätszentrums für Friedensforschung Wien, 1996
- Erazim Kohák, Jan Patočka: Philosophy and Selected writings.
- Jacques Derrida, The Gift of Death
- Edward F. Findlay, Caring for the soul in a postmodern age : politics and phenomenology in the thought of Jan Patočka. Albany: SUNY Press, 2002.
- Marc Crépon, Altérités de l'Europe.
- Jan Patočka and the European Heritage, Studia Phaenomenologica VII (2007) - Ivan Chvatik (guest editor)
- Emre Şan, La transcendance comme problème phénoménologique: Lecture de Merleau-Ponty et Patočka. Paris: Mimesis, 2012.
- Francesco Tava, The Risk of Freedom: Ethics, Phenomenology, and Politics in Jan Patočka. London: Rowman & Littlefield International, 2015.
- Dariam Meacham & Francesco Tava (eds.), Thinking After Europe: Jan Patocka and Politics. Rowmand & Littlefield International, 2016.
*Daniel Epstein, [http://www.acheret.co.il/en/?cmd=articles.300&act=read&id=1897 Let us not despair of Europe, let us not despair of ourselves], [http://www.acheret.co.il/en Eretz Acheret] Magazine ...Comment:Is this broken link to be fixed or just here by mistake?<-->